New! Improved!! Public Schools --
Now with 50% More Education!!!
July 2008
by Matt Binz (Mr. HomeScholar)
It is amazing what you can find on Public Access TV on a lazy Saturday morning. For no apparent reason, I was watching a
Department of Education panel discussion featuring representatives of several charter schools in New Jersey. One school,
which had a waiting list of 1500 families, featured an extended school day (7:30 AM - 5:30 PM), an extended school week
(every other Saturday,) an extended school year (mid-August through the end of June) and truckloads of extended homework.
The panelist boasted that this allowed the students to get "50% more educational time" than other public school students.
The results? Average test scores went from the 15th percentile to the 75th percentile in four years.
Impressive? Absolutely, but at what cost....
"50 percent more educational time" can also be translated as "50% less time with the family." For younger kids, it also means "50% less time playing with friends," "50% less time for delight-directed learning," and "50% less time getting to know grandparents." For older students, it can mean "50% less time developing their area of passion," "50% less time giving back to the community through church or public service," and "50% less time for meaningful employment."
Are the results worth it? I suppose it depends on your perspective. If your goal is higher test scores regardless of the
collateral damage, then by all means. If your goal is growing children into educated citizens, while at the same time
building strong cross-generational relationships you might want to consider other options.
Homeschooling, whether classical, eclectic, or unschooling, is a profoundly efficient way to educate children. You can also gain that "extra FLAV-R boost" of an actual education while still having time for the other important aspects of growing up. Do we really need to sacrifice childhood, family, faith, and friends on the Alter of Education?
NO! Education is extremely important, but it is not the MOST important. Parents must keep a firm grasp on their ultimate goal and not accept the fashionable belief that a quality education is only possible by spending exorbitant amounts of time in a classroom.
But what makes homeschooling so efficient? I believe it is because of two fundamental factors: the teachers and the
learning environment. First, homeschooling is education delivered by people who know their children deeply, love them
profoundly and are committed to them unconditionally. In addition, homeschooling is education delivered in a secure
environment, absolutely devoid of harassment and intimidation. Taken together, these two factors have the same effect
on children as taking a regulator off of a high performance race car. We were absolutely amazed at the amount and the
speed at which our children learned when we started homeschooling. Those of us who "tasted public school" before beginning
homeschooling know this perhaps better than those who have homeschooled their children from the start.
The massive waiting list typical of Charter Schools indicates a profound hunger in society for improving the ways we educate our children. If you are seeking alternatives to what the current system offers, you need only to turn your heart towards home. Homeschooling through high school builds strong, confident and educated citizens while strengthening those vital relationships that will last a lifetime.
And you can do it in 50% less time, 100% less anxiety, and 1000% more confidence!
~~~~~
If you liked this article, please forward it to your friends at your homeschool group or coop, as well as friends who are considering homeschooling. They can sign up for The HomeScholar Record and get great homeschooling high school hints, tips and advice delivered to their inbox each month!
~~~~~
Email: Lee@thehomescholar.com
Call Toll-Free: 1-888-LEE-2HELP
"Your transcripts and records were
the best organized and documented I have seen"
~ Bryan Jones, Associate Director of Admissions,
Seattle Pacific University
Christianbook.com Curriculum Page
